Easter/Spring Cookies

I did another batch of cookies. This time it’s for my church’s bake sale. Mya helped by cutting out the cookies. With little kids, you kind of have to guide them as to where to place the cutters on the dough with the least waste. In my case, I placed the cutters and Mya pushed them down and popped them out. She also helped me roll out the dough using my nifty dowel guide system. Usually, she helps with the sprinkles but it was late at night when I decorated. Plus, she had a cold and I didn’t want her licking the sprinkles off her fingers then touching the cookies.

I donated 8 sets of 3 cookies, nicely packaged in cello bags filled with Easter grass. All the money goes to the church to pay for their eucharistic supplies. Luckily, I didn’t have to sit and sell these – the ladies at the Women’s Guild took care of that.

I was stuck as to how much I should price these. Thom, being the sales guy that he is said to price them at $6/set. But there’s a fine line between what they’re actually worth and what people at our church would pay. Honestly, the bake and craft sales have been dotted by middle of the road tasting and presented baked goods. It’s basically a bunch of quick-breads and cookies placed on a paper plate and wrapped in colored saran wrap. So cakes and breads were normally priced at around -. A plate full of cookies would go for a buck or two.

So I posted this pic on a message board I belong to and asked how I should price the cookies. I got ranges between $3-$5 —Which was pretty accurate in my mind. So I priced them at $5 per set.

Thom dropped the cookie bags off at church this morning. He said that they were the best looking cookies and the best presented items on the table. (I’ll get photos of the table later.) We didn’t stay for mass at our parish since we were going to the Mission (where we were married) for mass. So we couldn’t see the sales progress. Instead Thom called one of the volunteers after the bake sale to see how well they sold.

The verdict…

1. They’ve never had cookies that looked so good or were well presented.
2. They usually sell cookies for 50-75 cents a piece
3. All the bags sold at the $5 price
4. Everyone at the Women’s Guild were SHOCKED they sold for that much
5. We just made $40 for the church 🙂

It goes to show, putting your time and effort to make things nice will pay in the end. I’m glad I got to do my part in helping. Plus, I got to buy some fun cookie cutters out of it!

Next up… St. Patrick’s Day cookies! I’ll be baking about 150 shamrock cookies for a Lenten Fish Dinner this Friday. Whoo hoo! More cookie baking – more frosting!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.